-->
Tiananmen Square Man vs Tank
From FamousPicturesMagazine
|
|
||||||
| Picture Taken On: June 5, 1989 |
Place: The street name is Cháng Ān Dà Jiē (长安大街), or "Great Avenue of Chang'an" just a minute away from Tiananmen, which leads into the Forbidden City, Beijing |
Behind the Camera: Many photographers took the same shot from different angles. The most reproduced pictures is the one shown here by Jeff Widener of the Associated Press. Other photographers who captured the scene are Charlie Cole, Stuart Franklin, and a number of TV crews. |
Picture Summary: An unknown man blocks an advancing column of Chinese Type 59 tanks. |
||||
| First Posted:April 19, 2007 Last Updated on 2010-4-02 by Dean Lucas |
|
Video Breakdown
As shots can be heard in the background, the clip opens with a column of Chinese Type 59 tank rolling down Cháng Ān Dà Jiē (长安大街), or "Great Avenue of Chang'an" Blvd. A man, the Tank Man, wearing what appears to be a long sleeved white dress shirt and dark pants is standing in the middle of the road. While holding his jacket in one hand and shopping bags in another, he blocks the path of the tanks. The lead tank tries to drive around him but the Tank Man blocks the tank's path. Eventually he jumps up on the tank and at first tries to talk with the driver and then tries to talk through the main hatch on top of the turret. He then jumps off the tank and is bundled away by people standing on the street.
Background
The protests were sparked by the death of former Secretary General Hu Yaobang on April 15, 1989 a figure that many thought as unjustly persecuted by the Chinese government. The protests grew as different groups with a wide range of issues, some opposing in views, came to Tienanmen Square. The protests were extensively covered by Western journalists who were allowed into Beijing to cover the Mikhail Gorbachev visit in May. Chinese government was split on how to deal with the protesters but eventually the hard liners seized control of the situation and on May 20, the government declared martial law and, on the night of June 3 and the early morning of June 4, army tanks and infantry from the 27th and 28th Armies of the People's Liberation Army were sent to take control of the city. Local army units, the 38th Army, weren't used as the military feared they were too sympathetic to the protesters. In fact the commander of the 38th Army Xu Qinxian refused to carry out the martial law order and was relieved of his command.
In addition to the almost 300,000 military personal (Twice as large as the American force that overthrew the Saddam regime in Iraq) that were deployed were also members of the Public Security Bureau (PSB). The PSB is China's branch of government that handle policing, security and social order. By early morning on June 4 the protesters had been cleared from Tienanmen Square and over the next few days the army and the PSB brutally suppressed the students and any media caught covering the crack down.
| PSB agents crashed through our hotel room door | 
|
| —Charlie Cole | ||
One of the photographers, Charlie Cole, had spent the night running from police and the military. During the crack down he had witnessed an armored personal carrier (APC) that had run over some protesters. The outraged protesters then attacked the vehicle pulling out its drivers, killing them, and burnt the APC. While he was trying to get back to his hotel, he was attacked by PSB men, "One of the PSB ran up to me with a electric cattle prod and hit me in the side with it. Others punched and kicked at me. They ripped my photo vest off me and took all the film I had shot that evening." He was eventually let go and more importantly they let him keep his camera's. While in his hotel he started shooting from the balcony of a photographer friend's room, Stuart Franklin. Stuart had a room with a balcony on the 8th floor and while Charlie was shooting on the afternoon of the June 5th he saw the Tank Man stand down the column of tanks:
|
| It was an incredible thing to do, especially in light of what had just happened with the APC machine-gunners. I couldn't really believe it, I kept shooting in anticipation of what I felt was his certain doom.
To my amazement, the lead tank stopped, then tried to move around him but the young man cut it off again. Finally the PSB grabbed him and ran away with him. Stuart and I looked at each other in somewhat disbelief at what we had just seen and photographed. Later, Stuart left to go to Beijing University and I stayed behind to see what else might happen. Shortly after he left, PSB agents crashed through our hotel room door. Four agents swept in and assaulted me while a few others grabbed my cameras. They ripped the film from my cameras and confiscated my passport. They then forced me to write a statement that I was photographing during martial law, which unbeknown to me carried a hefty prison sentence. They then put a guard at the door. I had hidden the roll with the tank pictures in its plastic film can in the holding tank of the toilet. [Cole had hidden the rolls because he saw that PSB officials had noticed them taking pictures of the incident] When they left, I retrieved it and later made my way to AP to develop and transmit it to Newsweek in New York. Three other photographers also have the shot from different angles. Numerous inquiries have been made by various agencies and magazines trying to uncover the young man's identity and find out what happened to him. I've seen a number of accounts that name him as Wang Wei Lin, but that isn't a certainty. Personally I think the government most likely executed him. It would have been in the government's interest to produce him to silence the outcry from most of the world. But, they never could. People were executed at that time for far less than what he did. I think his action captured people's hearts everywhere, and when the moment came his character defined the moment rather than the moment defining him. He made the image, I just took the picture. I felt honored to be there. |
|
↓ Article continues below ↓
 Most Viewed Article |  Book Proposal | Most Famous Pictures Browse Images Altered Images |  All Images |  Newest Article |
Who is the Tank Man?
Little is publicly known of the man's identity and or his fate. It would have been in China's best interest that he be brought forward as proof that he wasn't executed but the Chinese have not been able to. This could mean any number of things including, that in the confusion following the crack down he was either killed on the streets or arrested and executed, or perhaps the PSB never identified who he was. So basically you have two schools of thought. One that he was arrested and the other that he managed to slip away.
Arrested
|
| But I think never never killed |
|
| —Chinese General Secretary Jiang Zemin | ||
The arrested side believes that the people who hustled the Tank man away were PBS agents and even if they weren't they don't believe that the Tank man could have slipped past security.
- Reporter Charles Cole thought quite strongly that he was executed.
While shooting the pictures from the hotel he noticed many PBS officials on the rooftops who appeared to be coordinating snatch teams on the ground. Plus he witnessed a lot of public executions put on Chinese TV for people that had done far less offenses.
- Three weeks after the protest Alfred Lee of the British tabloid,
Sunday Express, broke a story where he named the Tank Man, Wang Weilin (王维林), a 19-year-old student and son of a Beijing factory worker. In Alfred's report he wrote that Wang Weilin's friends had seen him on with a shaved head and paraded on state television. Recalling his story, Alfred lee remembers getting the new from his sources in China, "These contacts were very close to what was happening at Tienanmen Square at the time. I knew that once his name had come into the public domain, the Chinese authorities wouldn't be able to do anything to him. They couldn't execute him. It would have brought outrage from the world." Five days after Alfred's story the, London Evening Standard, reported their Beijing correspondent John Passmore had come across intelligence reports that Weilin had been executed. Alfred Lee's story has never been fully excepted by journalists or government agencies. Reporters note that Alfred wasn't working in China at the time and that other journalists who had excellent contacts, fully fluent in Chinese were never able to confirm the story. Even John Passmore denies that he reported Wang Weilin's execution saying that it was a mistake by the Standard that his name was used.
Slipped Away
The slipped away side, view the people that ran out to get him as being just ordinary people who then slipped away into the crowds.
- Jan Wong journalist for the Canadian paper the Globe and Mail points
to the footage of the Tank Man being pulled away from the tanks as proof the men weren't security agents, "If you've ever seen security people manhandle a Chinese citizen, they're really brutal. They twist your arm. They make you bend over. They punch you a few times. They kick you. So to me, I think he was helped to the side of the road. He wasn't being arrested." Jan Wong claims that the man is alive and well hiding in communist China.
- One account has him making it to Taiwan, where he worked for the National Palace Museum but other media have never been able to track him down and the Museum denies that he works there.
China follows a policy of total silence when talking about Tiananmen Square protest and the Tank Man's fate. Officials have only spoken about it once, in a 1990 interview with Barbara Walters. Then-CCP General Secretary Jiang Zemin was asked what became of the man:
|
| BARBARA WALTERS, ABC News: What happened to the young man?
JIANG ZEMIN: I think this young man maybe not killed by the tank. BARBARA WALTERS: No, but did you arrest him? We heard he was arrested and executed. JIANG ZEMIN: [through interpreter] Well, I can't confirm whether this young man you mentioned was arrested or not. BARBARA WALTERS: You do not know what happened to him? JIANG ZEMIN: But I think never never killed. BARBARA WALTERS: You think he was never killed. JIANG ZEMIN: I think never killed. BARBARA WALTERS: Never killed. |
|
Aftermath
No one knows for certain how many people died during the Tiananmen Square massacre. The Chinese Red Cross at first reported 2,600 killed but then under intense government pressure retracted the total. The official government body count is 241 dead, including 23 officers and soldiers, and 7,000 wounded. After the crackdown China moved on with its economic reforms and since the protest is taboo to discuss, most young Chinese don't even know it happened.
Mar 24 2010 1:31 am
This is one of the most powerful photos I've ever seen -- it defines what courage is. We give credit to generals and presidents, when in fact it is the unknown that make history. It's just as well that he remains nameless.